AskYourStay vs Hostfully: Which Is Better?
An honest comparison of AskYourStay and Hostfully for vacation rental hosts. We cover features, pricing, setup, and which tool is the better fit for your situation.
The quick verdict
Hostfully is the closest competitor to AskYourStay. Both solve in-property guest information. The key difference: Hostfully gives guests a digital guidebook to READ. AskYourStay gives guests an AI to TALK TO. Guests can ask questions that no guidebook anticipated. If you want a visual property guide, choose Hostfully. If you want guests to get instant answers to any question, choose AskYourStay.
Pricing comparison
AskYourStay
From £5/mo
Starter plan. Pro at £9.99/mo.
- 30-day free trial, no credit card
- No per-property fees on Starter (up to 3)
- Cancel anytime
Hostfully
$8-$19/property/mo
Guidebook plan from $8/mo, PMS from $19/mo
- 14-day free trial
- Founded 2016
Feature comparison
| Feature | AskYourStay | Hostfully |
|---|---|---|
| AI-powered guest chat | Full AI concierge (Claude) | |
| QR code access | QR to AI chat | QR to guidebook |
| Multilingual support | 50+ language chat | Translation tools |
| 24/7 instant responses | ||
| Digital guidebook | AI-powered equivalent | |
| Property management | Optional add-on | |
| Interactive Q&A | ||
| Local recommendations | AI-curated, conversational | Static lists |
| Setup time | Under 5 minutes | 1-2 hours |
| Guest interaction style | Two-way AI conversation | Read-only guidebook |
Where each tool wins
Choose AskYourStay if you want...
- AI conversation vs static guidebook (guests can ASK questions)
- Faster setup (5 min vs 1-2 hours of guidebook creation)
- Automatic multilingual support (no manual translation)
- Guests get answers to questions not covered in any guidebook
Choose Hostfully if you want...
- Beautiful visual guidebooks with photos and maps
- Optional PMS features for property management
- Established platform with large user base
Who is Hostfully best for?
Hostfully is best for: Hosts who want digital guidebooks for their properties with optional property management features.
AskYourStay is best for: any vacation rental host who wants to stop answering repetitive guest questions. Whether you manage one property or fifty, the AI concierge handles WiFi passwords, check-in instructions, local tips, and appliance guides 24/7 in any language.
Can you use both together?
Yes. AskYourStay focuses on in-property guest support (the questions guests ask after they arrive). Hostfully focuses on digital guidebooks and property management. These are complementary tools. Many hosts use a property management platform alongside AskYourStay to automate both the booking lifecycle and the in-stay experience.
Frequently asked questions
Is AskYourStay better than Hostfully?
Hostfully is the closest competitor to AskYourStay. Both solve in-property guest information. The key difference: Hostfully gives guests a digital guidebook to READ. AskYourStay gives guests an AI to TALK TO. Guests can ask questions that no guidebook anticipated. If you want a visual property guide, choose Hostfully. If you want guests to get instant answers to any question, choose AskYourStay.
How much does Hostfully cost compared to AskYourStay?
Hostfully costs $8-$19/property/mo. AskYourStay starts at just £5 per month for the Starter plan and £9.99 per month for Pro. Both include a free 30-day trial with no credit card required.
Does Hostfully have AI guest messaging?
Hostfully does not offer AI-powered guest messaging. AskYourStay uses Claude AI to provide full conversational responses to any guest question in 50+ languages, accessible via QR code in the property.
Can I use AskYourStay and Hostfully together?
Yes. AskYourStay focuses on in-property guest support via QR code and AI chat. Hostfully focuses on hosts who want digital guidebooks for their properties with optional property management features. Many hosts use both tools together for complete automation.